I first saw Nobody Passes Perfectly, a Germany documentary and one of the latest additions to BuskFilms’ catalogue, at a UK film festival in 2009. It had an indelible impact on my understanding of gender, sexuality and trans identity, and I’ve been talking it up to friends ever since. Beautifully and compassionately shot, it is certainly one to ruminate on and, in my view, only improves with repeat viewing. To celebrate its new found wide availability, I was keen to hear and share others’ reactions upon watching the film for the first time:
Scott Larson, USA
Nobody Passes Perfectly introduces itself as open-minded, and could be described as open-ended. The film never introduces the speakers, offers a back-story, nor places them in a narrative of before-and-after transition. Rather, the camera places the viewer in the position of a “fly on the wall” in a series of conversations and vignettes focusing on the lives and transitions of trans-masculine individuals.
The film means to be intimate, and feels familiar to me as a trans-man: certainly I have had conversations much like those in the film. Like its framing, the film leaves open the questions of what manhood and masculinity mean, and why it matters in the first place. Moreover, the film allows questions of masculinity to be in tension with categories of sexuality. It neither resolves nor covers over the often-uncomfortable fit between gender transition and categories of sexuality that rely on seemingly fixed or well-defined gender. It asks critical questions about the value of bodies and the film’s speakers insist that bodies matter—how they look, how they feel, and how they allow one to feel at home or out of place in social worlds.
The openness of the film is its greatest asset, but I wonder if the film’s focus on masculinity leaves open the suggestion that masculinity somehow stands outside or apart from other major forms of identity. That is, masculinity seemed complex and nuanced, but femininity and women less so, and the film did not touch on issues of race, class, immigration, access to health care.
While I don’t expect that every project can or should address every issue, the strength of the film is that it opens the door to further questions, and those are some of the questions I pose in thinking more about the film. I would recommend it as a resource to people who are thinking personally about their own gender identity, but also to people who want to know more about gender identity broadly and engage in further discussions—either personal or academic—about different ways that people engage issues of genders, bodies, and sexualities.
Greg Sensing, US
Nobody Passes Perfectly is a smart, gorgeous film. I really enjoyed the fly-on-the-wall perspective, rather than having different people talking at the camera, conducting another “Transgender 101 class.” It’s nice to see more human, real conversations about what gender identity really means.
There are no “rules on how to be a man” but more discussion about what that even means, and allows that not every transgender person is interested in trading one binary gender experience for another one. There’s far more nuance and complexity in gender identity and expression, for every person. It’s great we get to eavesdrop in on those conversations.
The notion that transgender people might not want to just be a man or just be a woman, that maybe we enjoy “being a freak” because it’s awesome to be transgender, is sadly a really radical idea in a lot of documentaries on the subject, just because society is still (slowly) wrapping its collective brain around the concept. Reality is so much more interesting than that.
Kai Côté, Canada
A few parts in the movie really resonated for me. One is how it’s brought up that, even if it might take years for someone to acknowledge they need to transition, when it’s realized it feels like it was always meant to be. It becomes obvious and clear: it needs to happen. However, it can still be very hard to express the process behind it, feeling whole and real without necessarily having to attach a label to it or try to fit in anywhere, to just be and do what is needed to bring happiness.
Another compellingly made point is that, for some trans-men, it’s not so much ‘passing’ as a man [that matters] but more so not being pressed into a female mould. I can relate to that. I’m more concerned with not being seen as a woman than being seen as a man. It opens up a whole new world of gender possibilities to be whoever I want to be by not being seen as a woman. But I also don’t only want to be seen as a man because that would only be a part of myself.
I really like how it’s brought to our attention that cis men can also feel like they don’t fit in according to the stereotype of what it is to be a man, or feeling like a man but not the man that society wants you to be. Transgender or not, we can all feel like we don’t fit in at some point in our life.
Ruth Pearce, UK
This is a gentle, thoughtful, reflective film. It doesn’t really feel like there’s a clear beginning or end to any of the narratives that lie at its heart: instead, thoughts and feelings ebb and flow as two transmasculine individuals explore gender with partners and friends.
I enjoyed the way in which gender and identity were portrayed as fluid, complex, deeply personal yet intimately linked to others. I almost wish I could have watched a film like this prior to my own transition: when I wondered how it felt to experience hormone therapy; whether I would become a different person, and how this would impact my relationship. Ultimately, everyone responds differently to the changes that come with both physical and social shifts in gender.
Similarly, I felt the tableaux benefited from multiple perspectives on gender itself. There were none of the essentialist assumptions that are all too present within mainstream trans documentaries: instead, we see individuals discussing hormone therapy and the concept of manhood in terms of what felt right for them.
Of course, the spectre of discrimination was ever-present. One participant suggested that he took testosterone because he could no longer deal with street harassment, and there were several reflections upon how others might react negatively to the changes that come with transition. Nevertheless, the overall mood is one of quiet celebration, lauding human diversity and individuality within a complicated world.
Please feel free to add your own comments to this thread, or under the film itself.






So, how was your Valentine’s Day? Do anything nice? The highlight of my day was being handed a chocolate heart by an ill-at-ease college freshman promoting a Libertarian Summer Camp. Where’s Cupid’s arrow when you need it? The rest of the day I spent telling friends: “I love you, with or without VD!”
Others have opted for pithier analyses. The New York Times, in an 



